Tag: Land Rights

  • Vietnam Briefing: Vietnam “Concerned” About The Situation in Ukraine, Plans To Evacuate Its Citizens

    Vietnam Briefing: Vietnam “Concerned” About The Situation in Ukraine, Plans To Evacuate Its Citizens

    The Vietnam Briefing, which is released every Monday morning Vietnam time, looks at Vietnam’s social and political developments of the past week.

    Source: The Vietnamese Magazine


    Vietnamese courts approve appeal requests for local activists

    • On February 14, the Hanoi Supreme People’s Court sent a notice to attorney Dang Dinh Manh that on January 27 it had approved his application as a defense lawyer for the appeal trial of journalist Pham Doan Trang.
    • The court’s decision was followed by Doan Trang’s request for an appeal after her conviction of “distributing anti-state propaganda” and received nine years of imprisonment. The appeal hearing is expected to take place within 90 days of the approval day.
    • Also, the family of activist Do Nam Trung announced last week that the Hanoi Court on the same day had approved attorney Dang Dinh Manh as a defense lawyer for his appeal hearing. Trung was given a 10-year prison sentence for “distributing anti-state propaganda” last year, which was considered relatively harsh given his less well-known activism.
    • Meanwhile, attorney Manh also told RFA Vietnamese in an interview that he would defend Le Huu Minh Tuan, a member of the Independent Journalists Association of Vietnam (IJAVN), in his appeal hearing scheduled on February 28. Tuan was sentenced to an 11-year prison sentence in January 2021, along with two other members of IJAVN, on allegations of “distributing anti-state propaganda.
    • At the same time, Tran Quoc Khanh, who self-nominated himself as a candidate for Vietnam’s National Assembly elections last year, had his previous conviction upheld at an appeal trial on February 17. Khanh was sentenced to six and a half years of imprisonment last October under allegations of “distributing anti-state propaganda.”

    Vietnamese court to try another independent journalist on “anti-state” charges

    • The Hanoi People’s Court is scheduled to hold a trial on March 11 for the independent journalist Le Van Dung, commonly known by his pen name Le Dung Vova, on accusations of “distributing anti-state propaganda,” according to his defense lawyer Ha Huy Son.
    • Dung, 52, was detained in late June last year after the police issued a national warrant for his arrest. He was on the run when the investigation authorities announced their decision to prosecute and arrest him in May 2021.
    • Le Van Dung owned a Vietnamese language personal media channel, Chan Hung Nuoc Viet TV, where he reported and live-streamed his comments on different social and environmental issues. According to Dung’s family, the evidence used to prosecute him mostly consists of his online live streamings.
    • Attorney Son also told RFA Vietnamese during an interview that his client’s health and mentality remained stable.

    Local citizens assaulted over land rights disputes

    • Last week, a video showing a group of people wearing uniforms beating up several female protesters was widely circulated on Vietnamese social media. The conflict was later confirmed to have occurred at a construction site on February 18 in Hoang Hoa District, Thanh Hoa Province.
    • According to RFA’s investigation, the citizens who were assaulted during the conflict are members of a local family who had disputes over land ownership with an investment company called Flamingo. The company is carrying out a luxury resort project at the locality. Meanwhile, the attackers were said to be Flamingo’s security guards.
    • Tran Huy Hiep, who recorded the video, and who also has a land ownership dispute with Flamingo, said that his land was forcefully confiscated by the investment company without any compensation. When asked about whether or not his family had informed the provincial authorities of the conflict, Hiep said his family had contacted the district authorities, but that they claimed that “the land was owned by the local district government” and therefore it has the right to “sell that [land] to the company.”

    The Archdiocese of Hanoi calls for respect for religious freedom in a letter to authorities

    Agenzia Fides:

    • On February 24, the Catholic Church in Hanoi sent a letter of urgent complaint to various Vietnamese provincial and national authorities and called on the People’s Committee of Hoa Binh Province to respect the religious freedom and pastoral activities of the Catholic faithful in the province.
    • The letter was published four days after two people entered the Vu Ban Church in Hoa Binh Province, taking the microphone from the pulpit and ordering those attending mass to disperse for “pandemic control” reasons. The people are the secretary of the Communist Party of the city of Vu Ban City, Pham Hong Duc, and vice-president of its People’s Committee, Pham Van Chien.
    • In the published letter, the Archdiocese of Hanoi said: “This is a disrespectful act, an abuse of power that seriously violates the right to religious freedom, the right to the religious practice of bishops, priests and laypeople.”
    • The statement also said that this gesture “is unacceptable in a country where the rule of law prevails” and it “has aroused indignation and the pain of those who attended the mass as well as all those who saw the images on the web and social media.”

    The Vietnamese government, “concerned” about the situation in Ukraine, plans to evacuate citizens

    • In a statement on February 25, the spokeswoman of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Le Thi Thu Hang said Vietnam “is concerned about the armed conflict in Ukraine” and that it called on involved sides “to exercise restraint, abide by the United Nations Charter and basic principles of international law,” among other things.
    • The country, however, did not condemn Russia’s military operations against Ukraine while only describing the invasion as “armed conflict” on state media.
    • At the same time, Vietnam Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has ordered the Ministry of Transport to prepare plans to evacuate Vietnamese citizens and their families in Ukraine, VnExpress reports. According to government numbers, there are about 7,000 Vietnamese people living in Ukraine, mainly in Kharkiv, Odessa, and Kyiv.

    U.S. envoy for climate vows to help Vietnam meet key COP26 commitment

    VnExpress:

    • The U.S. special presidential envoy for climate, John Kerry, has expressed his appreciation for Vietnam’s COP26 commitments and reaffirmed the U.S. pledge to assist the country with this effort.
    • Kerry, who paid a four-day visit to Vietnam starting February 22, said the U.S. stood ready to assist Vietnam in reviewing, adjusting its strategy, and planning towards the goal of achieving net-zero emissions by 2050, a key commitment announced by Vietnam’s leaders at COP26 in the United Kingdom last November.
    • He also added the United States would continue to work closely with Vietnam on specific and timely measures, especially in developing renewable energy and reducing emissions, formulating policies to phase out coal power, and developing sustainable infrastructure.

    Forbes Vietnam removes a man from its Under 30 list following harassment allegations

    VnExpress:

    • Ngo Hoang Anh, 22, has been removed from the Forbes Vietnam Under 30 list, the magazine announced Thursday. The Forbes list published on February 14 honors Anh in the field of science and education, but it drew a backlash after several high school classmates said they had been verbally harassed by him.
    • “Regarding the case of Ngo Hoang Anh, after carefully considering all aspects of the issue, including the inspirational spirit of the list and Ngo Hoang Anh’s wishes in an email sent to the magazine, Forbes Vietnam decided to withdraw him from Year 2022 Under 30 list.”
    • The Forbes Vietnam 30 Under 30 listing has been honoring Vietnamese youth in several areas including businesses and startups, science and education, social activities, art, entertainment, and sports.

    Vietnam Hit by Fuel Shortages as Hundreds of Retailers Run Dry

    Bloomberg:

    “Vietnam is suffering from fuel shortages with hundreds of retailers forced to halt sales, prompting Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh to order an investigation of the market, including imports and exports of gasoline.

    Nearly 300 petrol and oil retailers across the country have stopped product sales, according to the trade ministry, which carried out a round of inspections. Reasons ranged from insufficient supplies from wholesalers and distributors to workers contracting Covid-19, it said. Local media have published photos of shuttered petrol stations displaying signs that they had run out of gasoline.”


    Vietnam Insight: Learn more about Vietnam

    On Ukraine crisis, Vietnam media stray from typical pro-Russia coverage

    RFA/ RFA Staff/ February 24

    “When the so-called Euromaidan protest movement rocked Ukraine in 2014, followed by the Russia-Ukraine conflict that led to the annexation of Crimea by Russia, Vietnamese state-run media generally blamed the crisis on “the West.” Fault was seen to lie with the U.S. and on NATO expansion aimed at bringing Ukraine out of Russia’s sphere of influence.

    Today, the picture is different.”

    Looking beyond the tip of Vietnam’s corruption iceberg

    East Asia Forum/ Hai Hong Nguyen/ February 23

    “With public attention increasing, the Viet A case will serve as a ‘test kit’ for Trong and the CPV’s anti-corruption efforts. Vietnamese netizens are embroiled in the question of the true perpetrators behind this multi-million-dollar case. Some suspect the case is wholesale ‘state manipulation’ beyond just a few bad actors. Regardless, Phan Dinh Trac, an assistant to Trong in the CSCC and Head of the Central Commission for Internal Affairs (CCIA), recently affirmed that the CCIA would pursue the Viet A and other grand corruption cases to the end despite mounting pressure.”

    President Phuc Wants To Solidify Vietnam’s Strategic Ties With Singapore

    Eurasia Review/ Veeramalla Anjaiah/ February 25

    “With a population of about 100 million people and a dynamic market profile (low-cost labor, rapid-growing economy, and strategic location among other strengths), Vietnam is an appealing target for Singapore partners to establish businesses.

    Vietnam needs a strong supporter like Singapore in its conflict with China. The aggressive behavior of China in the SCS and growing tensions between China and the US are threatening the peace and security in the region.”


    💡
  • Pham Doan Trang in East Asia Forum: Vietnam’s path forward on COVID-19 and corruption

    Despite the robust export-led economy, Vietnam is performing very dismally in safeguarding the people’s basic human rights including press freedom and land rights.  Prominent journalist and human rights defender Pham Doan Trang is one of the many whom the CPV has imprisoned to deliberately cleanse Vietnam’s public space of citizens it perceives as troublemakers.


    Excerpt:

    The regime continues to cleanse Vietnam’s public space of citizens it perceives as troublemakers. Journalist Pham Doan Trang, sentenced in December to nine years in prison, was one of many convicted in 2021 of ‘conducting propaganda against the state’. In parallel, harsh sentences meted out to farmers accused of mounting an insurrection put land rights activists on notice that resistance to expropriations is futile.

    In December, after exposes that made headlines abroad, Facebook vowed to cease enabling regime efforts to suppress online criticism by Vietnamese bloggers. Hanoi has in the past brought foreign social media to heel simply by squeezing their local advertising revenues.


    Download:

  • Pham Doan Trang in CIVICUS: Repression persists as Vietnam jails human rights defender Pham Doan Trang and other activists.

    Since October 2021, several activists, journalists and human rights defenders including Pham Doan Trang have been harassed, arrested and convicted by the authorities simply for exercising their freedom of expression.  CIVICUS examines how Vietnam’s civic space has been continuously repressive, even putting pressure on Facebook to remove “anti-state” posts and silence anti-government critics in Vietnam.


    Excerpt:

    Vietnam’s civic space rating remains ‘closed’ in ratings published by the CIVICUS Monitor in December 2021. Among concerns raised by civil society through the year were the use of restrictive laws to criminalise activists, the targeting of journalists, surveillance and allegations of torture and ill-treatment.

    In January 2022, Human Rights Watch (HRW) published its annual report which found that the Vietnamese government hid behind the COVID-19 pandemic to carry out a severe crackdown on peaceful activism. HRW said that people who publicly criticise the government or Communist Party leaders on social media routinely face harassment, intimidation, intrusive surveillance, restrictions on freedom of movement, physical assault and arrest. After being detained for exercising their rights, people face abusive interrogation, long detention periods without access to legal counsel or their families, and trial by politically controlled courts meting out increasingly lengthy prison sentences.

    Since October 2021, the authorities have convicted sentenced human rights defender and journalist Pham Doan Trang to nine years’ imprisonment as well as five journalists of the now-shuttered Báo Sạch (Clean Newspaper). A number of individuals have been arrested and convicted for exercising their freedom of expression online while Facebook was accused of removing “anti-state” posts. Others arrested or jailed include political and land rights activists.

    Expression

    Prominent human rights defender and journalist jailed

    🇻🇳#Vietnam: The decision to sentence #humanrightsdefender Pham Doan Trang to 9 years in jail sends a further chilling message for media freedom and freedom of expression in the country.

    ✊We stand with her and other convicted activists and will keep demanding their release. pic.twitter.com/lG0R3xgFlV December 21, 2021

    Human rights defender and independent journalist Pham Doan Trang was sentenced to nine years in prison by The People’s Court of Hanoi on 14th December 2021. She was arrested in Ho Chi Minh City on 7th October 2020 and charged under Article 88 of the 1999 Criminal Code which criminalises “making, storing, distributing or disseminating information, documents and items against the Socialist Republic of Viet Nam.”

    The indictment in Pham Doan Trang’s case includes as evidence several of her published works on environmental and human rights issues, as well as two interviews she gave to Radio Free Asia and the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC).

    In a statement released ahead of her trial, Pham Doan Trang wrote, “The longer the prison sentence, the more demonstrable the authoritarian, undemocratic and anti-democratic nature of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.”

    According to Amnesty International, Pham Doan Trang was held incommunicado from the time of her arrest until 19th October 2021, when she was finally allowed to meet with one of her lawyers after having been denied access to her family and legal representation for over a year.

    On 25th October 2021, the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD) issued Opinion No. 40/2021 concerning Pham Doan Trang. The WGAD found her detention to be arbitrary and called for her immediate release.

    Pham Doan Trang is among the leading voices and best-known independent writers in Vietnamese civil society and recognised internationally for her human rights advocacy. She is the author of thousands of articles, blog entries, Facebook posts and numerous books about politics, social justice and human rights.

    In 2019, Reporters Without Borders awarded her a Press Freedom Prize in recognition of her impact. Her work at the Liberal Publishing House helped it receive the prestigious Prix Voltaire award in 2020 for its continued coverage in spite of risks and dangers of reprisals. On 20th January she was named this week as a recipient of the 2022 Martin Ennals Award for Human Rights Defenders, the first rights activist from Vietnam to be given the award.


    Download:

  • Pham Doan Trang in RFI Tiếng Việt: Báo cáo vụ Đồng Tâm : “Những khuất tất của chính quyền Việt Nam”

    Luật Khoa magazine editor Pham Doan Trang is also one of the authors of the Dong Tam Attack Report, a 28-page document forwarded to international human rights organizations and delivered to the office of a US Congressman.  In this interview, Ms. Pham shares their basis for coming up with the document and what they hope to achieve.


    Full transcription in Vietnamese:

    Phạm Đoan Trang : “Vụ việc này đầy khuất tất từ phía chính quyền. Điểm đáng nói đầu tiên là về cái chết của ba sĩ quan công an. Công an nói có ba chiễn sĩ hy sinh, bị quân khủng bố phóng hỏa, giết. Trên mạng có những bức ảnh cho thấy thi thể của ba người này chỉ còn là than. Bản báo cáo về vụ Đồng Tâm chỉ ra rằng, bình thường cơ thể con người, để thành tro cháy gần hết như vậy cần mất khoảng ba hay bốn tiếng. Không có lý gì lực lượng công an để đồng đội của họ cháy trong ba tiếng đồng hồ mà không dập lửa. Cũng như là bom xăng, một chai xăng mà đơn vị đo là 0,65 lít thì không thể gây ra một vụ cháy kinh hoàng như vậy. Tường nhà thì không ám khói, không có dấu vết của một vụ hỏa hoạn. Điểm đáng ngờ thứ hai liên quan đến cái chết của cụ Kình. Cụ bị giết thế nào ? Ai giết ? Tại sao lại bị mổ tử thi ? Biên bản khám nghiệm tử thi ấy đâu ?

    Điểm thứ ba là cáo buộc của chính quyền nói cụ Kình và gia đình, dân Đồng Tâm là khủng bố, tàng trữ vũ khí. Vậy chính quyền đã biết chuyện những người dân Đồng Tâm tàng trữ vũ khí -nếu có, từ thời điểm nào ? Nếu biết từ trước tại sao không xử lý đúng quy trình tố tụng ? Thí dụ như thông báo trước, thậm chí có thể đến vây hãm, yêu cầu đầu hàng. Nhưng ít nhất phải chờ đến khi bên trong có động thái, thí dụ như bắt con tin, hay đe dọa sát hại con tin trong nhà thì mới có thể tấn công. Nếu như họ vẫn ở trong nhà và cố thủ thì vẫn phải đợi. Bạo lực chỉ là biện pháp cuối cùng. Ngoài ra còn có vấn đề những người khác bị bắt, bị ép cung, tra tấn. Dấu hiệu rõ ràng là nếu chỉ đánh nhau bình thường, mặt không thể có những vết bỏng. Không thể có những vết cháy trên mặt. Đó là dấu vết của sự tra tấn rất rõ”.

    Mục đích báo cáo về vụ Đồng Tâm là gì ?

    Phạm Đoan Trang : “Chúng tôi nhận thấy rằng, từ trước đến giờ, trong tất cả những sự kiện tương tự hoàn toàn nhà nước độc quyền phát ngôn. Trong vụ Đồng Tâm, câu chuyện đến một mức quá xa, nghĩa là nhà nước không chỉ phát ngôn mà còn đàn áp thẳng cánh những người cung cấp thông tin. Trong một tuần lễ, tôi biết có ít nhất ba người bị công an bắt vì đã đưa tin trái chiều về Đồng Tâm. Đưa tin và quan điểm về Đồng Tâm. Thậm chí chỉ chia sẻ bài trên Facebook. Bài có nội dung trái với những gì truyền thông nhà nước đã đưa. Cho nên chúng tôi quyết định, trong một thời gian cực ngắn, chỉ 2 ngày, để làm báo cáo đó.

    Chúng tôi muốn là có một nguồn thông tin tham khảo dành cho cộng đồng quốc tế cũng như là cho người trong nước. Chúng tôi mong muốn vấn đề sẽ được quốc tế hóa, được cộng đồng quốc tế, các chính phủ, những nước dân chủ và các tổ chức quốc tế về nhân quyền như Human Rights Watch hay Amnesty International, lên tiếng, gây sức ép buộc chính quyền Việt Nam cho phép điều tra độc lập, hoặc thừa nhận tội lỗi của mình. Hay ít nhất là giảm án, bảo vệ những người đã bị bắt. Hiện giờ những người chưa bị bắt, những nhân chứng còn sống sót bị đe dọa khủng bố rất kinh hoàng”.


    Full Transcription in English:

    Pham Doan Trang:“This case is full of uncertainty from the government side. The first point worth mentioning is about the deaths of three police officers. The police said that three soldiers died, were set on fire and killed by terrorists. Online there are The photos show that the bodies of these three people are reduced to coal.The report on the Dong Tam incident indicates that, normally, the human body, to burn most of the ash, takes about three or four hours. There is no reason for the police force to let their comrades burn for three hours without putting out the fire.Like a petrol bomb, a bottle of gasoline that measures 0.65 liters cannot cause a fire. The house was so horrifying, the walls of the house were not covered with smoke, there was no trace of a fire. The second point of suspicion concerns the death of Mr. Kinh. How was he killed? Who killed? Why was he operated on? Where’s the autopsy report?

    The third point is the government’s accusation that Kinh and his family and people in Dong Tam are terrorists and possess weapons. So the government knew about the Dong Tam people’s possession of weapons – if so, when? If you knew in advance, why didn’t you handle the proceedings properly? For example, advance notice, maybe even siege, requesting surrender. But at least you have to wait until there is an action inside, such as taking hostages, or threatening to kill hostages in the house, before you can attack. If they were still at home and entrenched, they would still have to wait. Violence is only a last resort. There is also the issue of others being arrested, forced to surrender, tortured. The obvious sign is that if it’s just a normal fight, the face can’t have burns. There can be no burn marks on the face. It’s a very clear mark of torture.”

    What is the purpose of reporting on the Dong Tam case?

    Pham Doan Trang : “We have found that, in all similar events, the state has completely monopolized the speech. In the Dong Tam case, the story goes too far, that is, the state. In a week, I know at least three people were arrested by the police for reporting conflicting information about Dong Tam. Tam. Even just shared the article on Facebook. It had content that was contrary to what the state media had reported, so we decided, in a very short time, just 2 days, to do that report.

    We want to be a reference source for the international community as well as for local people. We hope the issue will be internationalized, voiced by the international community, governments, democratic countries and international human rights organizations such as Human Rights Watch or Amnesty International. Vietnamese authorities allow independent investigation, or admit guilt. Or at least reduce the sentence, protect those who have been arrested. Now for those who have not been arrested, the surviving witnesses are facing terror threats.”