Tag: Pham Doan Trang

  • Vietnamese Vision Of A “Clean Newspaper” And The Government’s Intolerance To Press Freedom

    Vietnamese Vision Of A “Clean Newspaper” And The Government’s Intolerance To Press Freedom

    This year as the world triumphs the importance of free speech with the award of the Nobel Peace Prize to two journalists, Maria Ressa and Dmitry Muratov, for their “efforts to safeguard freedom of expression,” Vietnam has taken a step backward in its respect for press freedom by arresting and imprisoning independent journalists.

    On October 26, the local Court of Can Tho City began to try five members of the Bao Sach (Clean Newspaper) group, a Facebook-based journalism project, for allegedly “abusing the rights to freedom and democracy” that the government deemed “threatening” to state interests and security. Two days later, on October 28, five members of Bao Sach were sentenced to a total of 14 years and six months in prison.

    Meanwhile, the Court of Hanoi City is also expected to try prominent journalist Pham Doan Trang for “propagandizing against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam;” the evidence used to prosecute Doan Trang includes her written reports and assessment regarding environmental issues, the human rights situation, and religious freedom in Vietnam.

    In some ways, when we congratulate the two journalists who were awarded the prestigious Nobel Peace Prize in 2021, Maria Ressa of the Philippines and Dmitry Muratov of Russia, we also feel saddened to think about the Bao Sach members and Pham Doan Trang. These Vietnamese journalists have been facing never-ending hurdles reporting the truth under the repressive hands of authoritarian leaders.

    Vision for a better journalistic environment in Vietnam

    Established in 2019, Bao Sach started off as a Facebook-based project which investigated and reported on the alleged corruption and misconduct of Vietnamese government officials and state-owned companies. Corruption and mismanagement are ubiquitous in Vietnam’s governance system. The project quickly attracted a substantial number of followers in its fan page on Facebook, as the role of the social network in Vietnam is similar to its neighbor, the Philippines, where it is essentially viewed as the Internet.[1]

    The journalistic group’s name, Clean Newspaper, refers to its commitment to journalism ethics by truth and impartiality rather than becoming another mouthpiece of the Communist government. Bao Sach gained popularity through its fact-based and accurate reporting that helped expose and provide insights into the many social issues to which the Vietnamese public pay attention, most notably the case of Ho Duy Hai, who was given the death penalty in an unfair trial.

    However, being a vocal critic in a tightly controlled media environment comes with a cost. Not much different from what Rappler Founder Maria Ressa [2] faced as a journalist in the Philippines, independent journalists, and human rights activists in Vietnam also live in constant fear of harassment by government-funded online trolls and arbitrary arrests and charges under vague laws, which have no purpose other than to curb freedom of expression.

    Bao Sach’s (Clean Newspaper) members. Photo: RFA.

    Late last year, Truong Chau Huu Danh, one of the co-founders of Bao Sach, was arrested by the police, which marked the end of one of the promising independent media projects in Vietnam. Bao Sach’s Facebook page was shortly suspended after Danh’s apprehension; three members were arrested earlier in April this year.

    Subsequently, they were charged with “abusing the rights to freedom and democracy to infringe on state interests” under Article 331 of Vietnam’s 2015 Penal Code, which has been strongly criticized [3] by the international community and legal authorities for its vagueness and lack of clear definitions of the actual conduct.

    Similarly, Doan Trang’s vision [4] of a journalism project to provide Vietnamese people with an understanding of law, politics, and human rights also led to her arrest and detention. She was charged with “propagandizing against the State,” another criminal charge commonly used by the Vietnamese government to suppress dissenting opinions in the country.

    The Vietnamese government’s intolerance to press freedom

    Nevertheless, the Bao Sach members and Doan Trang are among dozens of independent reporters, journalists, and broadcasters constantly harassed or detained by the Communist authorities. Critical reporting of online bloggers and live-streamers also meets with increasing censorship as Facebook, Vietnam’s most popular social media site has in recent years reportedly complied with the government to remove “anti-state” posts. According to local activists and free-speech advocates, [5] the tech giant’s compliance is giving the Vietnamese authorities “near-total control over the platform.”

    Despite the Vietnamese Communist Party trying to boast and propagandize [6] about its state of press freedom and its respect for human rights, Vietnam scores poorly on almost every international ranking regarding press freedom and fundamental civil rights.

    Vietnam ranks [7] at 175th out of 180 countries on the 2021 World Press Freedom Index from Reporters Without Borders in terms of free press. It is also among those countries with the highest number of detained journalists, according to figures [8] compiled by the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) in 2020.

    Vietnam ranks 175th out of 180 countries in terms of press freedom. Photo: screenshot/ Reporters Without Borders.

    On civil rights, Freedom House, a non-partisan organization working to promote freedom and democracy, declared that Vietnam was “not free” when it comes to internet freedom. The Vietnamese government later criticized the results, allegedly requesting Freedom House to “stop making groundless assessments” [9] on the situation of internet freedom in the country. However, the government failed to provide concrete evidence to explain its alleged repression of internet users’ rights, other than a few fragmented pieces of information bragging about the country’s growth in internet users and its Human Development Index.

    The journey to a truly free, progressive, and independent media environment in Vietnam is still long and arduous, given the arbitrary arrests of independent journalists in recent years and an increasingly restricted social media space. However, if Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh wants to realize his pledge [10] to “listen to dissenting opinions [and] debates,” then Vietnam must respect freedom of the press and allow journalists to express their viewpoints freely. It would also contribute to the long-term development of both Vietnam as a country and its journalistic environment.

    References:

    1. Vick, K. (2021, October 8). “It Is a Battle for Facts.” What Nobel Peace Prize Winner Maria Ressa Understands About Why She Was Chosen. Time. https://time.com/6105407/maria-ressa-nobel-prize-interview/
    2. Andrew Yeo, Enrico Gloria. (2021, October 21). In a first, the Nobel Peace Prize went to a Filipina. Her government isn’t happy. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/10/21/first-nobel-peace-prize-went-filipina-her-government-isnt-happy/
    3. The Vietnamese Magazine. (2021, October 26). Statement On The Upcoming Trial Of Bao Sach (Clean Newspaper). The Vietnamese Magazine. https://www.thevietnamese.org/2021/10/statement-on-the-upcoming-trial-of-bao-sach-clean-newspaper/
    4. Tran Phuong, Will Nguyen. (2021, February 14). Who Is Pham Doan Trang? The Vietnamese Magazine. https://www.thevietnamese.org/2021/02/who-is-pham-doan-trang/
    5. Elizabeth Dwoskin, Tory Newmyer, Shibani Mahtani. (2021, October 25). The case against Mark Zuckerberg: Insiders say Facebook’s CEO chose growth over safety. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/10/25/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-whistleblower/
    6. Đối diện: Nhân quyền. (2021, October 27). VTV. https://vtv.vn/video/doi-dien-nhan-quyen-527961.htm
    7. Vietnam – Reporters Without Borders. (n.d.). Reporters Without Borders. Retrieved October 28, 2021, from https://rsf.org/en/vietnam
    8. Record number of journalists jailed worldwide. (2020, December 15). Committee to Protect Journalists. https://cpj.org/reports/2020/12/record-number-journalists-jailed-imprisoned/
    9. VNA, (2021, September 29). Freedom House should stop making groundless assessments on internet freedom in Vietnam. VietnamPlus. https://en.vietnamplus.vn/freedom-house-should-stop-making-groundless-assessments-on-internet-freedom-in-vietnam/208842.vnp
    10. Tuan, V. (2021, April 15). Thủ tướng Phạm Minh Chính: “Chính phủ phải lắng nghe ý kiến phản biện.” VnExpress. https://vnexpress.net/thu-tuong-pham-minh-chinh-chinh-phu-phai-lang-nghe-y-kien-phan-bien-4263570.html
  • Pham Doan Trang’s Trial Postponed While UN Working Group On Arbitrary Detention Called For Her Immediate Release

    Pham Doan Trang’s Trial Postponed While UN Working Group On Arbitrary Detention Called For Her Immediate Release

    Vietnam arrested Pham Doan Trang on October 7, 2020, and charged her under Article 88 of its 1999 Penal Code for allegedly “making, storing, distributing or disseminating information, documents, and items against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.” Her trial was originally scheduled to take place on November 4, 2021, but the court postponed her trial due to the prosecutors having come into contact with COVID-19.

    However, on October 25, 2021, the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD), a team of five independent experts tasked with investigating “cases of deprivation of liberty imposed arbitrarily or inconsistently with the international standards set forth in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,” released their opinions regarding the arrest, detention, and treatment by the Vietnamese state of internationally recognized independent journalist and human rights defender Pham Doan Trang.

    In this document, WGAD scrutinizes the formal statements given by the side of Doan Trang and that of the Vietnamese government in order to verify the authenticity of the claims regarding her situation in custody and to provide recommendations for the Vietnamese government.

    WGAD also stated that even though the Vietnamese government vehemently rejects the accusations alleged by the side of Doan Trang and that “[the Vietnamese government] cannot provide detailed information regarding this case to the press and other irrelevant parties,” WGAD will still continue with its investigation as part of its mandate “to serve the needs of victims of arbitrary arrest and detention worldwide.”

    WGAD concluded that “the deprivation of liberty of Pham Doan Trang, being in contravention of articles 2, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 19, 20 and 21 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and articles 2, 9, 14, 15, 16, 19, 21, 22, 25 and 26 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, is arbitrary and falls within categories I, II, III, and V.”

    Regarding Doan Trang’s arrest by state forces, WGAD believes that the Vietnamese authorities failed to present a warrant for her arrest and that Doan Trang was not informed of the charges lodged against her. She was also never brought before an independent judicial authority in order to challenge her detention.

    Likewise, WGAD upholds that Doan Trang was put under Incommunicado Detention which “is an environment conducive to torture and cruel inhumane treatment, as it may be used to coerce the individual to confess to the commission of the alleged crimes and admit guilt.” Furthermore, WGAD states that the initial charge under Article 117 of the Vietnamese Criminal Code is “so vague that it is impossible to invoke a legal basis for her detention.” Hence, WGAD concludes that the Vietnamese government failed to establish a legal basis for Doan Trang’s arrest and detention.

    WGAD also believed that she was detained for “peacefully exercising her rights to freedom of opinion, expression, and association.”. As such, it has referred this case to the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression and to the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association.

    WGAD also stated that because Doan Trang was not allowed to speak to her defense lawyers until recently, and was denied legal counsel, her right to a fair and just trial has been violated.

    Likewise, WGAD found that Doan Trang was “deprived of her liberty on discriminatory grounds” due to her being a vocal human rights defender and because of her political stance and opinions.

    In light of all the information presented, WGAD requests that the Vietnamese government take all the necessary steps needed in order to remedy Doan Trang’s situation in order to “bring it into conformity with the relevant international norms.”

    WGAD believes that the best remedy would be to urgently and immediately release Doan Trang and compensate her in accordance with international law. WGAD also urges the Vietnamese government to ensure a “full and independent investigation” of Doan Trang’s arbitrary detention and to “take appropriate measures against those responsible for the violation of her rights.”


    The UN WGAD’s full statement can be found here

  • LIV Joins 27 Other NGOs In Issuing A Joint Statement Demanding The Immediate Release Of Pham Doan Trang

    LIV Joins 27 Other NGOs In Issuing A Joint Statement Demanding The Immediate Release Of Pham Doan Trang

    OCT 26 2021– Legal Initiatives for Vietnam (LIV), alongside 27 other non-governmental organizations (NGOs) released a joint statement calling for the immediate release of independent journalist and human rights advocate, Pham Doan Trang. Trang, one of the “best-known independent writers in Vietnamese civil society” who is also “recognized internationally for her human rights advocacy,” was arrested at her home in Ho Chi Minh City on October 7, 2020. She is currently being charged under Article 88 of the 1999 Penal Code which criminalizes ‘making, storing, distributing or disseminating information, documents, and items against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.’

    The statement comes ahead of Trang’s upcoming trial which is scheduled to take place on November 4, 2021. However, information about her trial was only made public on October 18, 2021, more than a year after her arrest.

    The joint statement claims that Pham Doan Trang’s persecution is due to her “long-standing work as an independent journalist, book publisher, and human rights defender, known for writing about topics ranging from environmental rights to police violence, as well as for her advocacy for press freedom.”

    Since her arrest, she has also been held incommunicado and has been denied contact with her family and her lawyers, only being allowed to get in touch with them on October 19, 2021, a day after the public announcement of her trial. Trang’s lawyer also notes that his client’s legs, which were broken in the past by the police in 2015, were in greater pain due to Trang being denied adequate medical care during her detention; she has also lost a lot of weight and has not been allowed to see any doctors to treat her other pre-existing medical conditions.

    In light of this information, LIV and its allies unanimously call for the Vietnamese government to:

    • Immediately and unconditionally release and drop all charges against Pham Doan Trang and all other human rights defenders currently imprisoned solely for the peaceful exercise of their human rights and fundamental freedoms;
    • Pending her immediate and unconditional release, guarantee humane treatment and conditions, and ensure prompt access to medical attention;
    • Guarantee Doan Trang unrestricted access to and regular communication with her family and confidential access to legal assistance of her choosing;
    • Ensure that her chosen lawyers are promptly provided with timely access to all relevant legal documentation and granted unrestricted communication and access in confidentiality with Doan Trang and adequate time and facilities to prepare for her defense;
    • Ensure the trial is open to the public, including diplomatic and human rights civil society observers and the media, and refrain from any arbitrary restriction on travel or interference of trial observers, media, and civil society preceding and during the trial;
    • Repeal or substantially amend the Penal Code and other non-human rights compliant legislation, used to harass and imprison individuals—including independent journalists and human rights defenders—for the exercise of their fundamental rights, and bring them in conformity with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights to which Vietnam has been a State Party since 1982, and other applicable international law and standards.

    ———-

    The full English text for the joint statement can be found here.

    The Vietnamese language version can be found here.

  • Vietnam Briefing: Indictment Against Journalist Pham Doan Trang Made Available; Vietnam Arrests Another Facebook User For Criticizing Its COVID-19 Policy

    Vietnam Briefing: Indictment Against Journalist Pham Doan Trang Made Available; Vietnam Arrests Another Facebook User For Criticizing Its COVID-19 Policy

    The formal indictment against journalist Pham Doan Trang made available for public, reports The Vietnamese Magazine

    Main points:

    • According to the indictment, the investigation was done between September 22, 2016 and October 7, 2020, which was also the day that the authorities arrested Doan Trang.
    • Doan Trang refused to provide the police with her laptop password and so the police could not access its data. She also refused to acknowledge her possession of the Facebook account named “Pham Doan Trang,” and therefore the investigative unit could not charge her in connection with the information posted via that account on social media.
    • Doan Trang acknowledged that she was one of the authors of the “Report Assessment of the 2016 Law on Belief and Religion in Relation to the Exercise of Freedom of Religion and Belief in Vietnam” in both English and Vietnamese. This report was published on the website of Luat Khoa Magazine.
    • As of the conclusion of the investigation into Doan Trang’s case on August 26, 2021, the authorities had not yet found any evidence to reduce her punishment.
    • The indictment stated that both the 1999 Penal Code and the 2015 Penal Code (which took effect on January 1, 2018) could be used to prosecute Doan Trang since she continued her unlawful conduct from 2017 to 2019. However, the government dropped charges under Article 117 and only prosecuted Doan Trang under Article 88 because it stated that Doan Trang did not provide any statement during her interrogations.
    • The 1999 Penal Code would be more beneficial to the defendant since Article 88 of that penal code starts the sentence at 3 years imprisonment versus 5 years imprisonment under Article 117 of the 2015 Penal Code.

    Evidence and final indictment:

    • English documents titled “A brief report on marine life disasters in Vietnam” and “General Assessment of the human rights situation in Vietnam;”
    • English and Vietnamese versions of the “Report Assessment of the 2016 Law on Belief and Religion in Relation to the Exercise of the Right to Freedom of Religion and Belief in Vietnam;”
    • Two interviews with Pham Doan Trang by BBC News Vietnamese and Radio Free Asia – Vietnamese (RFA) in 2018.
    • The Hanoi People’s Procuracy Office prosecuted Doan Trang under Article 88, Section 1, subsections a, b, and c for “propagandizing against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam” of the 1999 Penal Code. The sentencing for this crime will be three to 12 years imprisonment.

    Pham Doan Trang’s lawyers and family raise concerns over the deterioration of her health while in custody

    • On October 19, 2021, Le Van Luan, one of Pham Doan Trang’s defending attorneys, announced on social media that he had a formal meeting with his client and subsequently raised concerns about her deteriorating health conditions after a year of detention while pending trial. However, he said that she still maintains an optimistic and percipient mentality.
    • In his Facebook post, Luan shared that Doan Trang had lost 10 kilograms (around 22 pounds) over the past year due to suffering ovarian cysts and menorrhagia, a condition which has caused her periods to last as long as 15 days. The long periods and her low blood pressure have resulted in constant fatigue. According to Trang, the changing cold weather also made her legs feel painful; her legs were broken when she was attacked by security forces a few years ago. Trang said she had not received proper medical checkups or treatment while in custody.
    • On October 20, 2021, Doan Trang’s lawyers co-wrote a petition that they sent to the Hanoi authorities, requesting that they confirm the state of her declining health conditions and assist her with proper medical checkups and treatment. On October 22, Pham Chinh Truc, Doan Trang’s brother, sent an urgent petition regarding her health issues to the detention facility, demanding the officials in charge provide her with urgent medical care as well as improve her conditions in detention. Truc also requested the Hanoi authorities allow her a family visitation this October, followed by regular visitations every two weeks afterwards.

    Trinh Ba Phuong’s wife could not have visitation with him

    As we have previously published, the trial of two Duong Noi farmers, Trinh Ba Phuong and Nguyen Thi Tam, will be on November 3, 2021. They are both charged under Article 117 of the 2015 Penal Code for “propagandizing against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.” The 88 Project reported on October 25, 2021, that Trinh Ba Phuong’s wife, Thu Do, could not have visitation with him even the Hanoi’s People Court had allowed her.

    Accordingly, Thu Do received a letter from the Hanoi’s People Court informing her that she could visit her husband on October 21. “But when she got to the prison, she was turned away by prison officials who told her she could not see him due to COVID-19. When she asked to see the official paperwork with that decision, they produced an old order from April. They also refused to give her an explanation on paper. She has sent a complaint to the Court and the Ministry of Public Security about this and vowed to return next week,” The 88 Project stated.


    Detained blogger Bui Van Thuan’s family expresses concerns over his possible torture in detention

    RFA reports:

    • On October 15, Trinh Thi Nhung, Bui Van Thuan’s wife, received a notice from Thanh Hoa Province detention center, where Thuan is being held, regarding her husband’s health. The authorities informed Nhung that her husband had been admitted to a hospital for treatment of possible development of gout, liver infection and plantar fasciitis.
    • However, Nhung expressed concerns that Thuan might have been tortured while in custody since her husband has always had good health. The detention center officials declined to provide further information.
    • Bui Van Thuan was arrested on August 30, 2021 by Thanh Hoa Province police, just after U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris’ visit to Vietnam, where she raised concerns about human rights issues in the country. He was charged with “storing publications and materials against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam” under Article 117 of Vietnam’s Penal Code.

    Vietnamese Facebook user arrested for posting “distorted information on COVID-19 policy”

    VOA Vietnamese reports:

    • Vietnamese police in the city of Vung Tau arrested a Facebook user on October 21 for posting and sharing “false information on COVID-19 prevention policy” on his social media account.
    • Nguyen Thien Nghia, 50, was allegedly accused by the local public security department of posting “fabricated, false and distorted information on the government’s COVID-19 prevention policy.” His posts were seen criticizing the Ho Chi Minh City authorities’ coronavirus policies and the activities of Vietnamese Fatherland Front, a state-controlled political mass organization, for its fiscal misconduct and lack of support for the citizens financially affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.
    • He was detained and prosecuted under Article 179 of the Penal Code for “illegally transferring or utilizing information of computer and telecommunications networks.” Nghia is among dozens of people who were fined or prosecuted for criticizing the Vietnamese government regarding its controversial coronavirus policies.

    Bao Sach (Clean Newspaper) group’s trial is expected to begin on October 26

    • Last week, several state-run news outlets, including the military-owned People’s Army Newspaper, reported that the trial against the Bao Sach group, an independent journalism project, was expected to begin on October 26. Previously, the trial was due on October 12, but was subsequently postponed due to Vietnam’s COVID-19 pandemic situation.
    • Bao Sach members, including the former state journalist Truong Chau Huu Danh, were indicted last September by the People’s Procuracy of Can Tho City on charges of “abusing the rights to freedom and democracy to infringe on state interests” under Article 331 of Vietnam’s 2015 Penal Code.

    COVID-19 situation in Vietnam

    • Vietnamese prime minister promises economic revival after the COVID-19 pandemic, reports Reuters. On October 20, Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh told the National Assembly that Vietnam’s economy would rebound after the pandemic ended, with exports expected to rise 10.7 percent in 2021 and with annual inflation expected to fall below 4 percent. His statement came as a fast-spreading outbreak of the Delta variant led to mass lockdowns in the country’s key industrial provinces, causing disruptions in supply chains and labor shortages.
    • Vietnam resorts to China’s vaccine diplomacy supplies to ease COVID-19 infections in Ho Chi Minh City, despite reluctance from residents, writes Nikkei Asia: “China has announced donations of 5.7 million doses of its Sinopharm vaccine. The shot is not the preferred one for many Vietnamese, but it is helping to fill local supply gaps and is playing an increasing role in Vietnam’s inoculation campaign, which started later than those in some other countries.”
    • Vietnam’s labor paradox: Manufacturing industry caught in labor shortage problem after COVID-19 restrictions force workers to rush back to their hometowns, writes Nikkei Asia: “The summer brought pandemic-driven lockdowns to much of the country, which had forced workers to sleep at factories and prevented travel between provinces. As soon as officials pulled the barricades and barbed wire off the roads, tens of thousands of migrants rushed back to their hometowns.”
    • The 2021 Southeast Asian Games (SEA Games), which were planned to be held in Vietnam in November, have been postponed until 2022 due to the spread of COVID-19, reports the South China Morning Post. The biennial multi-sport event will be held in Hanoi during an unspecified two-week period in May, 2020.

    Satellite imagery shows Vietnam’s construction and land-filling in disputed Spratly islands

    RFA reports:

    • Commercial satellite imagery shows that Vietnam appears to be doing new construction and land-filling on the remote Pearson Reef, which it has occupied since 1978, and which it had previously reclaimed about six acres of land there.
    • The imagery, which was taken by Planet Labs on Friday, shows new work has been underway at the southern tip of the northern part of the reef when compared with a picture from March. The difference is even clearer when compared with an image from June 2020.
    • Pearson Reef is classified by the Washington D.C.-based Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative (AMTI) as a rock, 300 nautical miles east of Cam Ranh in central Vietnam. In Vietnamese, it bears the name of Phan Vinh, after Nguyen Phan Vinh, a hero soldier who died in 1968 during the Vietnam War.
    • On October 21, state media quoted a Vietnamese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokeswoman as saying that Vietnam adheres to international law and principles of peace, stability and cooperation regarding the South China Sea disputes. The statement came after Chinese state media CGTN publicly released footage on October 19 showing its military exercises in the disputed waters between two countries.

    Vietnam Insight: Learn more about Vietnam

    What’s Next for Indonesia-Vietnam Defense Relations?

    The Diplomat/ Prashanth Parameswaran/ October 20

    “Both countries [Indonesia and Vietnam] also addressed the future issues that they should prioritize in advancing their defense ties. According to the official account of the deliberations, these included areas such as technical cooperation between their coast guards, the development of military medicine amid the continued challenge of COVID-19, and other training exercises and high-level delegation exchanges. Indonesia’s defense ministry also highlighted the participation of defense industry companies in the virtual meeting, spotlighting an aspect that Jakarta has emphasized previously in defense ties.”

    Vietnam’s Economic Reopening: Finding the Right Balance

    Fulcrum/ Tuan Ho/ October 18

    “This presents Vietnam with the challenging task of ‘finding the right balance’ in its economic reopening process. On the one hand, Vietnam needs to ease social distancing measures as much as possible to revitalise the economy, which has been hard hit by the fourth wave of Covid-19 since late April.  Vietnam’s GDP contracted 6.2 percent in the third quarter, the largest quarterly decline recorded since 2000. The Asian Development Bank (ADB) has lowered Vietnam’s GDP growth forecast to 3.8 percent in 2021, a drop of 2 percentage points from a previous estimate made in July. Nguyen Kim Anh, the deputy governor of the State Bank of Vietnam, has warned that banks’ non-performing loans could reach between 7.1 and 7.7 percent of total outstanding loans, almost twice the estimate of 3.8 percent at the end of 2020. Further delays to full reopening will impede economic recovery and put further stress on the banking system.”

    Pacific Nations Have an Interest in Challenging China’s Expansive Maritime Claims

    The Diplomat/ Phuong Vu/ October 18

    “This is where small and non-claimant states, which benefit the most from a law-based international order in general and UNCLOS in particular, matter.  If they fail to form a consensus that views the South China Sea disputes and China’s interpretation of the law as a national threat, the repercussions will not stop at the water’s edge of current claimants such as Vietnam, the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia or Brunei. Small coastal and archipelagic states will incur expensive long-term costs for inaction. Through inaction, small states can effectively pave the way for a future where China will interpret the law for them.”

  • Pham Doan Trang’s Indictment Is Public Today; What Do We Know About Her Case?

    Pham Doan Trang’s Indictment Is Public Today; What Do We Know About Her Case?

    The indictment against journalist and democracy activist Pham Doan Trang was made public on October 18, Vietnam time. We are summarizing the main issues from the 15-page indictment, which you can read here in Vietnamese.

    The main points of the indictment are:

    • The indictment stated that the investigation was done between September 22, 2016 and October 7, 2020. October 7, 2020 was also the day that the authorities arrested Doan Trang.
    • The Department of Cyber Security and High Tech Crimes under the Ministry of Public Security (MPS), the national police in Vietnam, petitioned the investigation department to pursue legal proceedings against Doan Trang on May 4, 2020 and October 7, 2020 and included its documents and materials against her.
    • The Department of Information and Communications of Hanoi City also submitted two petitions with documents and materials to the MPS on December 26, 2017 and January 7, 2019, requesting legal proceedings against Doan Trang.
    • The Investigation Unit of Hanoi City’s Police formally opened the investigation on September 10, 2020.
    • The decision to initiate criminal proceedings against Doan Trang was issued on September 28, 2020.
    • Doan Trang was arrested under a warrant on October 7, 2020 in Ho Chi Minh City.
    • She refused to provide her laptop’s password to the police and accordingly, the police could not access its data.
    • She also refused to acknowledge the Facebook account of the name “Pham Doan Trang” belonged to her, and the investigative unit could not charge her for the information posted via that account on social media.
    • Doan Trang acknowledged that she was one of the authors of the “Report Assessment of the 2016 Law on Belief and Religion in relation to the exercise to Freedom of Religion and Belief in Vietnam” in both English and Vietnamese. This report was published on the website of Luat Khoa Magazine.
    • On February 19, 2021, the Authority of Information Security (under the Ministry of Information and Communications) submitted a document to the investigative unit which stated that it could not determine who owned and managed the domain name luatkhoa.org to pursue further legal proceedings against it.
    • The indictment stated that Doan Trang repeatedly committed unlawful conduct which can be used to increase her punishment.
    • The indictment also did not find any facts to reduce the punishment against her.
    • The investigation of her case was concluded on August 26, 2021.
    • The indictment stated that Doan Trang continued her unlawful conduct from 2017 to 2019 so both the 1999 Penal Code and the 2015 Penal Code (which took effect on January 1, 2018) could be used to prosecute her.
    • However, the indictment also stated that Doan Trang did not confess to any of these crimes and that the 1999 Penal Code would be more beneficial to the defendant since Article 88 of that penal code starts the sentence at 3 years imprisonment versus 5 years imprisonment under Article 117 of the 2015 Penal Code. Therefore, the government dropped charges under Article 117 and only prosecuted Doan Trang under Article 88.

    The Evidence against Pham Doan Trang under the indictment:

    • English document named “Brief report on the marine life disaster in Vietnam”;
    • English document named “General Assessments of the human rights situation in Vietnam”;
    • English and Vietnamese versions of the “Report Assessment of the 2016 Law on Belief and Religion in relation to the exercise of the right to Freedom of Religion and Belief in Vietnam”;
    • Two interviews with Pham Doan Trang by BBC News  Vietnamese and Radio Free Asia – Vietnamese (RFA) in 2018.

    Formal indictment:

    The Hanoi People’s Procuracy Office prosecuted Doan Trang under Article 88, Section 1, subsections a, b, and c for “propagandizing against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam ” of the 1999 Penal Code. The sentencing for this crime will be 3 to 12 years imprisonment.

    The indictment is dated August 30, 2021. However, it was only made public on October 18, 2021, in Vietnam, just more than two weeks before Pham Doan Trang’s trial. For almost two months, Doan Trang’s family and her attorneys, as well as the public, have been kept in the dark about the case Vietnam has against her.

  • Vietnam Briefing: Pham Doan Trang’s Trial Expected To Begin In November; Vietnam Slowly Reopening Its Economy After Long-Running COVID-19 Lockdowns

    Vietnam Briefing: Pham Doan Trang’s Trial Expected To Begin In November; Vietnam Slowly Reopening Its Economy After Long-Running COVID-19 Lockdowns

    Vietnamese court to try Pham Doan Trang and two farmer activists this November

    The Vietnamese Magazine reports:

    • On October 14, 2021, attorney Dang Dinh Manh, one of Pham Doan Trang’s lawyers, posted on his Facebook that the People’s Court of Hanoi will try the prominent journalist and writer on November 4, 2021. Also, according to Manh, the same court will try two of the Duong Noi land activists, Trinh Ba Phuong and Nguyen Thi Tam, one day earlier, on November 3, 2021.
    • Earlier, on October 6, the Hanoi People’s Procuracy Office notified Doan Trang’s family that they had decided to transfer the case to the People’s Court of Hanoi after recommending her indictment on August 30, 2021.
    • As of October 15, the government has not officially recognized or appointed any of the lawyers to be her legal representatives. As a result, both Doan Trang’s family and her attorneys have not received her indictment and still do not know what evidence the government has or the details of the charges against her. Doan Trang’s attorneys will file a motion to delay her trial so that they can better prepare for her defense
    • Pham Doan Trang marked her first year being held incommunicado last week. She is being charged with “conducting propaganda against the Socialist Republic of Vietnam,” which falls under Article 88 of the 1999 Penal Code. She faces the possibility of a 20-year sentence if convicted.

    Jailed Vietnamese land activist tortured to extract a confession

    RFA reports:

    • Jailed Vietnamese land activist Trinh Ba Tu was brutally tortured in detention as part of a bid by authorities to force him to plead guilty to charges of “anti-state activities,” according to his elder sister, Trinh Thi Thao. The alleged action by the Vietnamese authorities has prompted calls by human rights groups for an immediate investigation into his case.
    • On October 14, Thao told RFA Vietnamese that she met with her brother’s lawyers on Monday and learned that he had been badly beaten during an interrogation following his June 24, 2020 arrest. Tu laso reportedly required hospitalization for a kidney inflammation. “My brother Tu said that the prosecutor insulted him during the interrogation—the prosecutor’s name is Minh and he’s a prosecutor from Hoa Binh Province,” Thao said.
    • After receiving treatment, Tu was returned to detention and told to sign a false statement confessing to the crime of “creating, storing, disseminating anti-State materials” under Article 117 of Vietnam’s Criminal Code. The accusation is related to his online posts criticizing the government’s brutal handling of a long-running land dispute with Dong Tam villagers. “During the investigation process, investigators promised Tu that if he pleaded guilty, he would be jailed for only six years, but that otherwise he would have to serve eight,” Thao added.
    • Tu and his mother, Can Thi Theu, who was arrested the same day and similarly charged, were both sentenced on May 5 to eight years in prison and three years on probation. His brother Trinh Ba Phuong and land activist Nguyen Thi Tam were separately arrested on June 24 on the same charges of “propagandizing against the state.” Phuong and Tam remain in detention pending trial, which is expected to begin on November 3.

    A Protestant follower in Vietnam was arrested for “insulting” the Communist leader Ho Chi Minh

    VOA Vietnamese reports:

    • On October 14, Tra Vinh Province police arrested Thach Rine, a Khmer Protestant, for posting an edited portrait of late Communist leader Ho Chi Minh on his Facebook account, which was regarded as “defamatory” by the Vietnamese authorities.
    • However, according to some observers, the alleged arrest of Thach Rine was due to his religious beliefs and his activism for the human rights of indigenous Khmer Krom people. The local police had reportedly been watching Thach’s online political activities and periodically harassed and detained him.
    • On July 1, 2021, the Belgium-based Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organization (UNPO) criticized the Vietnamese government for the detention of Thach Rine for wearing a T-shirt with the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals logo advocating for indigenous people’s rights.

    Vietnam arrested and charged another member of the U.S.-based Provisional Government of Vietnam

    RFA reports:

    • On October 15, Vietnamese authorities arrested and charged a man with “carrying out activities to overthrow the government,” making him at least the fourth person this year apprehended for joining the Provisional Government of Vietnam, a U.S.-based exile Vietnamese organization branded by Hanoi as an overseas terrorist group.
    • Nguyen Doan Quang Vien, 39, of Lam Dong Province and Ho Chi Minh City, had asked to join the Provisional Government of Vietnam after learning of its existence on social media in 2017, according to a police investigation.
    • Authorities have this year arrested and convicted at least three people for allegedly joining the political group. In August, the court sentenced Tran Huu Duc of Nghe An Province to three years in prison and Ngo Cong Tru from Phu Yen Province to 10 years. Police detained another member, Le Thi Kim Phi from An Giang Province in September, but she has not yet been sentenced.

    COVID-19 situation in Vietnam

    • Several Vietnamese cities began to relax the months-long strict lockdowns and reopen their economies, while citizens were required to continue to follow pandemic preventive guidelines: Starting from 6 a.m., October 14, Hanoi will allow on-site dining and reopening of parks, hotels and public transportation as companies, offices and businesses resume operations as normal. Meanwhile, from October 6, the city of Da Nang will resume almost all of its production, tourism and service businesses, including indoor activities such as museums, cinemas, sports centers and amusement venues. The slow reopening takes place amid Vietnam switching from its zero-COVID policy to “living with the virus.”
    • Ho Chi Minh City police summoned members of Revival Ekklesia Mission, a Protestant organization, including juveniles aged from 11 to 13 years old, over its alleged accusation of “transmitting dangerous infectious diseases.” According to RFA and VOA Vietnamese, the church founders and its members were summoned on October 14 for further investigations regarding the incident on May 26, when a coronavirus cluster in the religious group was detected and believed to infect a large number of people. The local authorities later indicted the group for failing to follow health guidelines and causing the virus to spread, but its founders said that they had always properly complied with antivirus measures.
    • South Korea to donate over 1.1 million vaccine doses to Vietnam, writes The New York Times: “South Korea plans to ship almost 1.6 million doses of AstraZeneca’s coronavirus vaccine to Vietnam and Thailand this week, the foreign ministry announced Tuesday, as the Southeast Asian nations struggle to contain the spread of the virus. […] About 1.1 million doses will go to Vietnam and 470,000 to Thailand, South Korea’s government said.”
    • Vietnam received nearly another two million Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccines from the United States, bringing the total number of doses that the country received from the United States to 9.5 million. The U.S. Department of Defense also provided Vietnam with 111 ultra-low temperature freezers for vaccine storage, according to a statement by the U.S. Embassy in Hanoi.
    • Vietnamese factory workers hesitate to return to work amid the COVID-19 pandemic, worsening the problem of global supply chains, writes Bloomberg: “Now staff-starved companies are imploring workers like My to return for what would normally be peak production for winter clothing and Christmas gifts. The government is offering transportation back and companies are upping pay and benefits, but little is working.” It was estimated that around 1.3 million migrant workers had returned to their hometowns between July and September due to the COVID-19 pandemic and harsh lockdown mandates.

    Vietnam’s coal-fired electric generation may double by 2030 under draft power plan

    Reuters report:

    “Vietnam may double the amount of coal-fired electric generation it installs by 2030 under a draft power development plan submitted to the prime minister for approval this week.

    The draft plan guarantees that Vietnam will become more reliant on coal to power its fast-growing economy at a time when financiers and insurers are refusing to back new projects because of fuel’s large climate change impact.

    Coal-fired power plants will account for up to 31.4% of as much as 143.8 gigawatts (GW) of installed generation capacity planned in 2030, according to a copy of the so-called Power Development Plan 8 (PDP 8) reviewed by Reuters.”


    Vietnam Insight: Learn more about Vietnam

    COVID-19 Made Life Even Worse for Japan’s Foreign Trainees

    The Diplomat/ Moeka Iida/ October 15

    “The trainee program depends upon the recruitment of young people from less developed economies who are desperate to work in advanced environments and eager to earn Japanese yen. However, there is a risk of exploitation even before these young recruits leave for Japan. Vietnamese trainees must pay a slew of pre-departure fees to brokers and sending organizations that push many to secure loans and mortgage assets. Although this amount varies, trainees can pay up to 1 million yen (around $9,000), plunging them into substantial debt.”

    How Asia’s Rice Producers Can Help Limit Global Warming

    The Diplomat/ Oliver Frith, Reiner Wassmann, Bjoern Ole Sander/ October 13

    “There are already several validated management options to mitigate methane emissions in rice, which maintain or improve yields, enhance profitability, and increase climate resilience. For example, integrating locally adapted best management practices with water-saving techniques, such as Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD), reduces methane emissions by 30-70 percent. In Vietnam, this has also improved farm profitability by up to 13 percent (around $100 per hectare).”

    Time is right for Vietnam’s digital transformation

    Asia Times/ Minh Ha Truong/ October 7

    “The timing couldn’t be better. With a population of 97 million, the Internet penetration in Vietnam is high, standing at 70% and increasing by 6.2 million in a single year. The nation is set to see its mobile transactions increase by 300% between 2021 and 2025 due to the strong growth anticipated in mobile payments.”

    Vietnam and Economic Reopening: Roadmap Needed

    Fulcrum/ Tuan Ho/ September 16

    “Facing economic slowdown pressures while still unable to control the pandemic, Vietnam is currently at a crossroads regarding its pandemic fighting strategy. While Prime Minister Chinh has suggested that Vietnam is shifting away from a ‘zero Covid’ strategy and preparing to ‘live with it’, the delay in reopening Ho Chi Minh City implies that some Vietnamese leaders are still embracing the idea of completely suppressing the pandemic, out of both public health concerns and possibly considerations about their political prospects. Their decision was also based on concerns that reopening the economy prematurely may be counter-productive.”

  • Vietnam Briefing: Pham Doan Trang Marks First Year In Jail; Vietnam Faces Labor Shortage As Migrant Workers Flee Industrial Cities For Home

    Vietnam Briefing: Pham Doan Trang Marks First Year In Jail; Vietnam Faces Labor Shortage As Migrant Workers Flee Industrial Cities For Home

    Journalist Pham Doan Trang marks her first year in jail

    • Around midnight on October 6, 2020, journalist Pham Doan Trang was arrested by the Vietnamese authorities and subsequently prosecuted on charges of “making, storing, spreading information, materials, items for the purpose of opposing the State of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.”
    • According to Doan Trang’s family, and one of her defending lawyers, Le Van Luan, the People’s Procuracy of Hanoi completed an official indictment against her and submitted her case to the People’s Court of Hanoi on August 30, but it did not notify her family and lawyers about the decision until October 6. Meanwhile, investigation results and the official indictment against Doan Trang have still not yet been made available.
    • Pham Doan Trang has been held incommunicado since her arrest and denied personal visitations by her family and lawyers.

    Vietnamese woman suing the authorities for alleged human rights violations

    RFA reports:

    • On Tuesday last week, Hoang Thi Phuong Lan, a Vietnamese woman who was violently forced by local authorities to take a coronavirus test, said that she would file a lawsuit against the government.
    • “I have the right not to let anyone touch my body, and what they did was absolutely wrong from a legal standpoint, and it also went against the regulations on pandemic prevention and control,” Lan said during a livestream video on her Facebook. “It was wrong that they decided to give me a fine even after they were able to get my specimen. Therefore, I am taking legal action,” she said.
    • According to Lan, she also received the local government’s decision to fine her two million dong (around US$88) for health law violations. Lan added that she was offered no opportunity to negotiate with local authorities on the decision.
    • However, Lan’s case is only one example of many incidents where Vietnamese authorities are caught on video committing coercive measures and violence against citizens during the COVID-19 pandemic.

    COVID-19 situation in Vietnam

    • As of October 10, 2021, Vietnam has recorded more than 836,000 confirmed COVID-19 cases, while the total death toll in the country has surpassed 20,000 fatalities. Less than 15 percent of the country’s population has received two doses of the COVID-19 vaccine.
    • Vietnamese authorities reportedly killed and cremated a local man’s pets as part of a COVID-19 preventive measure, causing a public outrage, reports VnExpress. Last Friday, Pham Minh Hung, a migrant worker in Long An Province, confirmed that his 13 dogs were killed by the local authorities in Ca Mau Province as he drove his wife and all of their pets on his motorbike while following his wife’s sister-in-law and her family to their hometown in Khanh Hung Commune, Ca Mau Province. At a checkpoint as they entered the locality, they tested positive for COVID-19 and were later transferred to an isolation facility for treatment; their pets were killed shortly afterwards over fear of the virus spreading. Another three dogs and a cat, which Hung previously gave to his accompanying relatives, also met the same fate.
    • Vietnam plans to reopen key tourist attractions for vaccinated tourists from approved countries, reports Reuters. From December this year, vaccinated tourists from countries with low COVID-19 risk will be allowed to visit the country’s popular destinations, including UNESCO world heritage site Halong Bay and Hoi An, the highlands town of Dalat and beach destination Nha Trang. The move is seen as an effort by the Vietnamese government to boost its heavily affected tourism sector, which has been hit hard by COVID-19 restrictions.
    • Ho Chi Minh City’s industrial workforce has shrunk as migrant workers returned to their hometowns, reports VnExpress: “Only 50 percent of employees have returned to work at industrial parks and export processing zones, causing a severe labor shortage. Pham Duc Hai, deputy head of the Ho Chi Minh City Steering Committee for Covid-19 Prevention and Control, said on Monday that of around 288,000 workers, only around 135,000 have turned up.”
    • Return of migrant workers to Mekong Delta provinces sparks fears of potential COVID-19 outbreaks, reports VnExpress. According to local authorities, the insufficient isolation capability of localities, the substantial number of returning workers and limited medical capacity have become major concerns for receiving provinces in the event of an outbreak.
    • COVID-battered supply chains set Vietnam on a shaky road towards recovery, writes Nikkei Asia: “But a potential recovery remains precarious, said Tuan Chu, an economist at RMIT University Vietnam, pointing to two labor risks. Thousands of jobless migrants fled Ho Chi Minh City as soon as lockdown eased on Friday. The city counted 288,000 workers in industrial areas before the exodus, compared with 135,000 now. Besides worker scarcity, Chu said this mass migration could trigger a rise in virus cases in the provinces. Will authorities invoke lockdowns again if the caseload explodes? That is a worry that also may keep job-seekers from returning to economic zones, he said.”
    • The public is calling on the government to set price controls for COVID-19 test kits as shortages, alleged price gouging and government corruption may have caused price surges, reports RFA: “Though rapid test kits cost around 35,000 dong (US$1.54) on the international market, a lack of supply in the Southeast Asian country forced provinces and cities to bid against each other, causing wholesale prices within the country to skyrocket, said Dang Hong Anh, chairman of the Vietnam Young Entrepreneurs Association.”
    • COVID-19 vaccines to arrive in Vietnam: On October 6, Australia delivered over 300,000 AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine doses to Vietnam while promising to assist the country in purchasing another 3.7 million doses. Meanwhile, on October 8, the United States Embassy in Hanoi announced that 397,800 doses of Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine had arrived in Vietnam, with more vaccines to arrive in a few days, bringing the total number of vaccine donations from the United States to Vietnam to nearly 8.5 million doses.

    Vietnam arrests a Facebook user for criticizing the government’s controversial COVID-19 policies

    RFA reports:

    • On October 4, Vietnamese authorities arrested a Facebook user and subsequently charged him with “abusing freedom and democracy” for writing a series of online posts they said had defamed the country’s leaders.
    • Vo Hoang Tho, 36, a resident of Vietnam’s southern city of Can Tho, had allegedly published 47 posts on his Minh Long Facebook page criticizing government efforts to prevent and control the spread of COVID-19 in the one-party Communist state, according to state media.
    • The Vietnamese government’s controversial COVID-19 policies to contain the pandemic, which include community lockdowns and other harsh restrictions, are widely unpopular in Vietnam. Tho’s arrest was just the latest in a continuing crackdown on Facebook users who use the popular social media platform to voice dissenting views.

    Vietnam calls on China to be accurate and objective with history regarding the Chinese television series “Ace Troops”

    VnExpress reports:

    • On October 7, state media reported that Foreign Affairs Ministry spokeswoman Le Thi Thu Hang had called on China to look at history ‘accurately and objectively’ while responding to questions about “Ace Troops,” a Chinese television series, with allegedly inaccurate and wrongful historical depictions.
    • The allegedly historical inaccuracies were detected after comments made on social media platform Baidu regarding a trailer for “Ace Troops” described the story as being set in the 1980s when “the Vietnamese army was getting stronger […] and launching invasions into China.” Chinese website Manyanu said the series was about “Chinese soldiers in a self-defence counterattack against Vietnam,” which is regarded as contrary to facts by the Vietnamese netizens.
    • Hang said Vietnam requests that China properly abide by the mutual understanding of the important partnership between Vietnam and China, regarding “friendly and objective propaganda that fosters societal foundations beneficial for the development of both countries’ relations.” She also added that Vietnam’s consistent stand on historical issues is to “look towards the future” and to look at history “accurately and objectively.”

    Vietnam Insight: Learn more about Vietnam

    Vietnam’s Hidden Debt to China Expose its Political Risks

    The Diplomat/ Zachary Abuza, Phuong Vu/ October 8

    “Vietnam has famously eschewed China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), but it has been the recipient of over $16.3 billion in Chinese project financing from 2000-2017. A new report on Chinese economic assistance programs sheds some light on Vietnam and suggests that the country is increasing its debt burden to China far beyond what is commonly thought; creating political risk and impacting Vietnam’s potential policies toward its neighbor to the north, which is already prone to bullying and intimidation.”

    Counting the cost of Vietnam’s Covid collapse

    Asia Times/ David Hutt/ October 7

    “By late September, many of the lockdown measures were lifted in Hanoi, the capital. On October 1, Ho Chi Minh City’s industrial parks, construction projects, malls, hospitality facilities, and restaurants for takeaways were allowed to resume operations.

    While there is currently anger over how the communist authorities have handled the pandemic this year, seen in complaints and grievances posted on social media, not everyone believes that the ruling party’s reputation will suffer much in the long run.”

    Nominees and ‘Backyard Companies’: How Vietnamese Officials Conceal Their Illicit Wealth

    Fulcrum/ Le Hong Hiep/ October 7

    “As such, the absence of Vietnamese politicians and government officials in the Pandora Papers does not mean that Vietnamese officials are less corrupt than their foreign counterparts. A more plausible explanation is that they have other ways, though less sophisticated but still effective in the Vietnamese context, to hide their illicit wealth. One common measure is to use nominees to hold assets in Vietnam on their behalf.”

    From Delay to Desperation: The Story of Sinophobia and COVID-19 Vaccines in Vietnam

    The Diplomat/ Travis Vincent/ October 6

    “Yet the public does not see eye to eye with the communist government’s approval and purchase of Chinese vaccines. On top of that, many expressed distrust of and discontent with the government’s lack of transparency about the availability and allocation of vaccines, as well as the gravity of the pandemic situation in the economic hub of Ho Chi Minh City, which is now leading the country for both COVID-19 cases and fatalities, after an almost virus-free year.”

    Vietnamese rights activist marks first year in jail

    Asia Times/ Stewart Rees/ October 5

    “There is currently little to be positive about for proponents of free speech in Vietnam. Despite this, in February Vietnam announced its intention to run as a candidate for membership of the United Nations Human Rights Council for the 2023-2025 term.

    If Vietnam is serious about its desire to contribute to the development of global human rights it should look to put its own house in order first. Unconditionally releasing Pham Doan Trang would be a good place to start.”

  • Vietnam Says It Is Promoting And Defending Human Rights, But The Reality Proves Otherwise

    Vietnam Says It Is Promoting And Defending Human Rights, But The Reality Proves Otherwise

    In Vietnam, the beginning of this October marks two significant events that challenge and reflect upon the country’s actual circumstance over its commitment to uphold human rights values: the one year anniversary of the arrest of journalist Pham Doan Trang and the mass exodus of migrant workers who have had to use all sorts of means to return to their hometowns due to the lack of help from the government.

    Earlier, in March, Vietnam also announced its candidacy for the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) for the agency’s 2023-2025 term. This announcement has astonished many local pro-democracy activists and critics, who have expressed their opposition to such a move.

    According to the UNHRC’s membership requirements [1], member states running for the seats need to fulfill their “contribution to the promotion and protection of human rights,” and once they gain the council’s membership, the members must bear the responsibility to “uphold high human rights standards.”

    However, given the one-party Communist state’s poor human rights record and its consistently oppressive policies and actions in curtailing the people’s fundamental civil and political rights, Vietnam’s legitimacy to become a member of the UNHRC should remain out of the question [2].

    On the one hand, Vietnam’s state-controlled media has been seen praising [3] the country’s efforts in securing a seat at the United Nations body, betting on its early successful containment of COVID-19 and the donations of masks and medical equipment to other countries. From the government’s reasoning, keeping people safe and protecting their daily livelihoods are crucial to the promotion of human rights. “The country has tackled the pandemic head-on, putting the people at the center of all its efforts,” state media quoted Vietnamese Foreign Minister Pham Binh Minh as saying at the UNHRC’s 46th Regular Session.

    On the other hand, the apprehension of journalist Pham Doan Trang and the dire situation of Vietnamese migrant workers during the fourth wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in the country provide us with a contrasting narrative. Those unparalleled stories vividly portray an authoritarian government that shows virtually no tolerance for dissenting opinions, in addition to highlighting its disregard for the most basic human rights, which are recognized in the U.N.’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the country’s own Constitution.

    Pham Doan Trang and her freedom of speech

    Pham Doan Trang was arrested by the Vietnamese authorities at around midnight on October 6, 2020, and she has been held incommunicado since her detainment. Her arrest came only hours after officials from Vietnam and the United States held a video conference for the two countries’ 24th annual Human Rights Dialogue. However, Doan Trang, her friends and colleagues, and also the readers of her books, had long been anticipating her arrest.

    As a dedicated journalist and a prominent writer, Pham Doan Trang has devoted her career to documenting and writing about controversial social issues and human rights violations committed by the Vietnamese government. She also publishes books popularizing general knowledge about politics, laws, and human rights for the Vietnamese people.

    Pham Doan Trang and her book “Politics for The Masses.” Photo: Luat Khoa Magazine.

    In theory, the Vietnamese Communist Party (VCP) has consistently trumpeted[4] its respect for the people’s right to freedom of speech, right to access to information, and press freedom, which were promised to its citizens under the Constitution. But in reality, the VCP has systematically harassed and detained independent journalists and activists [5], restricted access [6] to critical online newspapers and blogs, including The Vietnamese Magazine and Luat Khoa Magazine, and tracked down and intimidated [7] anyone who disagrees with its political doctrine.

    To the international community and admirers of her work, Doan Trang has only done what a journalist should be doing: report truthfully and inform the global audience about alleged human rights abuses by the VCP. What the Vietnamese government has been doing to silence opposition critics and dissidents like her only exposes the country’s serious violations of basic human rights and its lack of commitment to steadfastly protect those fundamental rights of its citizens.

    The homebound journeys of Vietnamese migrant workers

    Also at the beginning of October, heartrending photos and video footage of thousands of migrant workers rushing to return to their hometowns were widely shared on Vietnamese social media. These migrant workers decided to flee big cities en masse due to financial difficulties that affected them as a result of COVID control measures and the lack of help from the government. “We are tired,” one migrant worker said [8].

    On their way home, many of the laborers were seen breaking through the barricades at checkpoints set up by local authorities, with many beaten by security forces and some even seen begging the officers to let them through. According to the government, these methods were to prevent the wave of mass migrations that resulted from concerns about the transmission of the coronavirus. Despite facing many hurdles and uncertainty during their homebound journeys, those migrant workers hardly had any other choice.

    Police and security forces guard a checkpoint in Ho Chi Minh City as people, who are mostly migrant workers, attempt to return to their hometowns. The photo was taken on September 30, 2021, by Reuters/ Stringer.

    This abrupt and large-scale migration wave was a result of Vietnam’s months-long abusive lockdown mandates [9], which largely excluded human rights matters from its protocols, and the negligence of the government regarding the well-being, and more importantly, the dignity of workers.

    As written in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Vietnamese people in general, and migrant laborers in particular, have the right to freedom of movement and residence within their own country; they also have the right to be treated with dignity and to seek their own security of life. Those allegedly unlawful actions by the Vietnamese government are clearly blatant violations of universal human rights, which are ironically the key conditions that the VCP must meet to gain its seat at the UNHRC.

    Steward Rees, an advocacy associate with The 88 Project, a non-profit organization that promotes free speech in Vietnam, suggests [10] that if Vietnam is genuinely serious about contributing to the development of global human rights, unconditionally releasing Pham Doan Trang would be a good place to start.

    References:

    1. Membership of the Human Rights Council. (2020). United Nations Human Rights Council. https://www.ohchr.org/en/hrbodies/hrc/pages/membership.aspx
    2. Jamal, U. (2021, March 17). Should Vietnam become a member of the UN Human Rights Council? ASEAN Today. https://www.aseantoday.com/2021/03/should-vietnam-become-a-member-of-the-un-human-rights-council/
    3. VNA. (2021, March 15). Vietnam stands for election to UNHRC in 2023–2025 tenure. VietnamPlus. https://en.vietnamplus.vn/vietnam-stands-for-election-to-unhrc-in-20232025-tenure/197570.vnp
    4. VNA. (2021b, July 8). Press freedom in Vietnam – Undeniable objective reality. VietnamPlus. https://en.vietnamplus.vn/press-freedom-in-vietnam-undeniable-objective-reality/204350.vnp
    5. Database of persecuted activists in Vietnam. (n.d.). The 88 Project. Retrieved October 6, 2021, from https://the88project.org/database/
    6. Freedom House. (2021, September). Freedom on The Net 2021 (Vietnam). https://freedomhouse.org/country/vietnam/freedom-net/2021
    7. Human Rights Watch. (2021). World Report 2021: Vietnam. https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2021/country-chapters/vietnam
    8. Reuters. (2021, October 4). “We are tired”: Workers flee Vietnam’s largest city as long lockdown eases. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/the-great-reboot/we-are-tired-workers-flee-vietnams-largest-city-long-lockdown-eases-2021-10-04/
    9. Nguyen, J. (2021, July 21). How The Latest Outbreak Reveals The Darker Side Of Vietnam’s Anti-Coronavirus Strategy. The Vietnamese Magazine. https://www.thevietnamese.org/2021/07/how-the-latest-outbreak-reveals-the-darker-side-of-vietnams-anti-coronavirus-strategy/
    10. Rees, S. (2021, October 5). Vietnamese rights activist marks first year in jail. Asia Times. https://asiatimes.com/2021/10/vietnamese-rights-activist-marks-first-year-in-jail/
  • Pham Doan Trang Is A Journalist, Her Profession Is Not A Crime

    Pham Doan Trang Is A Journalist, Her Profession Is Not A Crime

    As I am writing this beginning line, my mind is flooded with memories of Pham Doan Trang. I also realize that it has been almost seven years since I said goodbye to her before she left the United States to return to Vietnam. We had become friends and spent seven months together in the United States, and I have not seen her since December 2014. I also have not been able to contact her or speak with her on the phone since October 6, 2020. Vietnamese police arrested her near midnight that day in Saigon. My last text message to her was “Trang, answer me,” which I sent the night she was detained.

    Doan Trang can be classified as many things, depending on the person you speak with. She is a journalist, an activist, a teacher, a political person who opposes the Vietnamese Communist Party, a prominent figure of the democracy movement in Vietnam, and more. Yet, for me, Doan Trang is a friend, a very close friend, and that’s it. My only hope is to help set my friend free because she has not done anything wrong. She deserves to be free so that she can continue to write.

    And yet, sadly, her writing is precisely the reason that has put her in prison in Vietnam.

    In Vietnam, writing or producing verbal speech (YouTube, TikTok, etc.) can be a severe crime when you refuse to obey the government’s censorship system or self-censor on your own. If you look at the details of any political case in Vietnam, I guarantee that you will only find the alleged wrongdoings to be the uncensored writings and speeches produced by these defendants. It does not matter how the Vietnam government classifies their crimes as “abusing democratic rights” or “propagandizing against the state,” their crimes are always their writing and speech.

    For Doan Trang, I can also think of another aspect in which she has irritated the Vietnamese authorities even more. She was not just a journalist; she was also trying to encourage more people to write and be more aware of politics in Vietnam. I was one of the people she inspired to take writing as a profession and focus more on Vietnam’s human rights and political affairs.

    In my writing career, I have two people to be grateful for: my two co-founders of Legal Initiatives for Vietnam (LIV), Trinh Huu Long and Pham Doan Trang. If I had not met them in life, I don’t think I would have been confident enough to write in either Vietnamese or English, especially as a journalist.

    I left Vietnam and came to the United States when I was 12-years-old. I was not too young to think of myself as a native speaker in English, but I was not too old to be confident in my ability to write in Vietnamese either. However, after meeting Trinh Huu Long and Pham Doan Trang in 2014, they changed my life as I believed in their cause and decided to co-found LIV. Starting from that point, I began to promote human rights, democracy, and the rule of law in Vietnam through journalism. Trinh Huu Long may be the first teacher in journalism for me, but Doan Trang is the inspiration for my decision to change my career from law to journalism.

    Many people have asked me why I decided to quit my legal profession and started working for a non-profit organization that focuses on Vietnam. Maybe this career change was not advantageous for them and could be stepping down in life. But Doan Trang’s last words before she left the United States stuck with me throughout these years: “Every country needs a generation of young people who will sacrifice their lives to build a better society for others. If our generation refuses to take up this job for Vietnam, then who else will? Do we wait for the next generation to sacrifice for our country and choose an easier life now?”

    Doan Trang chose to take up this task to promote human rights in Vietnam, and she left America to go back to Vietnam, knowing that she would be imprisoned in the future. Then, for me, the decision of giving up my life as a litigation lawyer to write about human rights and political issues in Vietnam seemed to be a much easier job when I compared myself with Doan Trang.

    She’s inspired me, and we both have the same goal: to put Vietnam on the map for international audiences and encourage more Vietnamese people to care about human rights and democracy. To write about these issues should not be a crime in any nation because we only want to educate the public. What did we do so wrong that my friend Pham Doan Trang has spent one year incommunicado in Vietnam?

    The Vietnamese government cannot explain away Pham Doan Trang’s case or any political cases that have sent hundreds of dissidents to decades in jail. However, I hope the international community and foreign governments can speak up louder and be more explicit against this injustice.

    Journalism is not a crime; writing about politics and human rights is not a crime. Vietnam continues to suppress the free press and the freedom of speech much harder now, which is not an action the international community should condone. Please speak up for those imprisoned by the Vietnam government, such as Pham Doan Trang, because we are on the right side of history.